tony moly appletox smooth massage peeling cream

Exfoliating is an important part of the skincare regime because our skin cells die everyday, and they are left on the surface of the skin if we don’t exfoliate and remove them. Dull-looking complexion and blackheads are two problems lead about by that layer of dead skin cells on the skin. Also, without exfoliation, the goodness of your skincare products cannot penetrate easily into the skin! Horror!

Daily Vanity puts five exfoliators to the test and compare them according to the following criteria:

  1. How the skin feels after exfoliating
  2. For how long the effects last
  3. Whether it feels too harsh on the skin
  4. How it smells
  5. Overall impression

Let’s take a look at the five products we are comparing:

Bifesta Article Insertion (1)

Benefit B.right Refined Finish Facial Polish

Comparing 5 Popular Exfoliators Benefit B.right Refined Finish Facial Polish


This is one of the products that Benefit Cosmetics launched in its B.right skincare line. It is rather gentle scrub and has a floral scent that smells really good.

How to use: Apply the exfoliator onto skin (without wetting), put a ltitle water to allow the product to be spread across the skin. Then slowly massage.

Elishacoy Milk Cacao Black Sugar Scrub

Elishacoy is a Korean brand that is known for its skincare products and BB cream. This product smells like chocolate.

How to use: Apply it onto wet skin and massage.

Ginvera Green Tea Marvel Gel

Comparing 5 Popular Exfoliators Ginvera Green Tea Marvel Gel

This is probably oldest skincare products from the Ginvera skincare range and remains one of its bestsellers through the years. This has a herbal smell.

How to use: Apply onto dry skin and massage. Dry “particles” will be produced. Massage till no more “particles” are produced. Rinse off particles.

Skinfood Black Sugar Wash Off Scrub

Comparing 5 Popular Exfoliators Skinfood Black Sugar Wash Off Scrub

Sugar has been used as an exfoliator in several DIY mask recipes. Black sugar, in particular, is known for its hydrating properties.

How to use: Apply onto wet skin and massage.

Tony Moly Appletox Smooth Massage Peeling Cream

Comparing 5 Popular Exfoliators Tony Moly Appletox Smooth Massage Peeling Cream

The cute packaging will probably be the first to catch your eyes. This is one of Tony Moly’s bestsellers, together with Tomatox, a tomato-shaped oxygenated facial mask. This has a refreshing citrus scent.

How to use: Apply onto dry skin, massage and rinse off.

We accredited up to 5 points for each criteria up and tabulate the total score by adding up all the points. For how long effects last, if it’s one day, the product earns 1 point; if it’s two days, it earns 2 points.

Brands/Criteria Benefit Elishacoy Ginvera Skinfood Tony Moly
How skin feels
after using
3.5 2 4 3 4.5
How long effects
1 day Negligible 3 days 1 day 2 days
How gentle 3 2.5 3.5 1.5 4.5
How it smells 4.5 3.5 3 3 4.5
Overall impression 3.5 1.5 4 3 4.5
Total score 15.5 10.5 18.5 11.5 20


Have you tried any of these products? What is your favourite exfoliator?

Bifesta Article Insertion (1)

11 FREE things you can get from beauty boutiques and counters in Singapore!

This exclusive content can be yours for FREE when you sign up for the Daily Vanity newsletter, where we share even more useful beauty tips!
I agree to allow Daily Vanity Pte Ltd to include me in their mailing list for marketing and communications matters. I am able to request for my data to be removed from the site if required.
Kindly fill up your name.
Invalid email.
You will need to select the checkbox above to allow us to email you.

About the Author
Kristen Juliet SohKristen Juliet Soh is the editorial director of Daily Vanity, and has spent more than a decade in journalism and content strategy. When she's not at h...Read More